gosuprГосударственное управление. Электронный вестникPublic Administration. E-journal (Russia)2070-1381Факультет государственного управления МГУ имени М.В. Ломоносова10.55959/MSU2070-1381-102-2024-54-76gosupr-96Research ArticleЭКОНОМИЧЕСКИЕ ВОПРОСЫ УПРАВЛЕНИЯECONOMIC ISSUES IN ADMINISTRATIONБезопасность иностранных инвестиций в Китае: библиометрический анализ и системный комментарий к литературеSecurity Review of Foreign Investment in China: A Bibliometric Analysis and Systematic Literature Commentaryhttps://orcid.org/0000-0003-4555-2119ЧжаоЛ.ZhaoL.

Чжао Лили, Доктор юридических наук, профессор

Циндао

Zhao Li-li, DSc (Law), Professor

Qingdao

https://orcid.org/0000-0003-1716-8507ЧжанС.ZhangX.

Чжан Сюэ, Магистр права, ассистент

Тайань

Zhang Xue, LL.M., Assistant

Tai’an

zx6688738@163.comШаньдунский университет науки и технологийShandong University of Science and TechnologyТайшаньский колледж науки и технологийTaishan College of Science and Techonology20242205202601025476Copyright © Чжао Л., Чжан С., 20262026Чжао Л., Чжан С.Zhao L., Zhang X.Данная работа распространяется под лицензией Creative Commons Attribution 4.0.This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 License.https://www.spajournal.ru/jour/article/view/96

Быстрое изменение мировой ситуации в области проверки безопасности иностранных инвестиций предъявляет более высокие требования к теоретическим исследованиям для построения и совершенствования китайской системы проверки безопасности иностранных инвестиций. С помощью программного обеспечения для визуализации CiteSpace в этом исследовании выбраны 304 наиболее цитируемые работы из базы данных CNKI, которые тесно связаны с обзором национальной безопасности иностранных инвестиций, в течение десяти лет с момента официального создания «Системы обзора безопасности иностранных инвестиций, слияний и поглощений» в 2011–2021 годах; проанализированы важные аспекты исследований, обобщены алгоритмы исследований, а также создана исследовательская сеть. Исследовательская сеть: исследование показывает, что существующие работы в этой области по-прежнему имеют проблемы, связанные с нестабильной сетью сотрудничества, узким охватом исследований, недостаточным вниманием к отечественным теориям и практике и недостаточными инновациями в содержании исследований, что не способствует продвижению научного развития исследований в области анализа безопасности иностранных инвестиций. В исследовании делается вывод о том, что последующие исследования в этой области должны быть сосредоточены на совершенствовании национальной нормативной системы для проверки иностранных инвестиций, проверки безопасности в области прав интеллектуальной собственности и взаимодействия с проверкой кибербезопасности и проверкой безопасности данных, с тем чтобы повысить потенциал национальной проверки иностранных инвестиций и обеспечить национальную безопасность.

The rapid change of global foreign investment security review situation proposes higher theoretical research requirements for the construction and improvement of China’s foreign investment security review system. With the help of visualization software CiteSpace, this study selects 304 high-quality documents in CNKI database that are closely related to national security review of foreign investment during the ten years from the formal establishment of the security review system of foreign investment and mergers and acquisitions from 2011 to 2021, analyzes the research hotspots, summarizes the research patterns, and builds a research network. Research network. The study finds that the current research in this field still has the problems of unstable cooperation network, narrow research scope, insufficient attention to domestic theories and practices, and insufficient innovation in research content, which is not conducive to promoting the scientific and reasonable development of the research in the field of security review of foreign investment. The study concludes that subsequent research in this area should focus on the improvement of the domestic normative system for foreign investment review, security review in the field of intellectual property rights, and the interface with cybersecurity review and data security.

Обзор безопасностииностранные инвестицииисследовательская сетьКитайCiteSpaceSecurity reviewforeign investmentresearch networkChinaCiteSpace1) «Исследование системы проверки безопасности данных об иностранных инвестициях» Министерства юстиции (22SFB2004); 2) Инновационная команда по управлению интеллектуальной научно-технической безопасностью Шаньдунского университета науки и технологий (2020RWB003).1) “Research on the Security Review System of Foreign Investment Data” of the Ministry of Justice (22SFB2004); 2) Intelligent science and Technology Security Governance Innovation Team of Shandong science and technology university (2020RWB003).ReferencesCai W. Legalization of National Security Review on Foreign Investment // Intertrade. 2020. Vol. 9. P. 90–96.Cai W. (2020) Legalization of National Security Review on Foreign Investment. Intertrade. Vol. 9. P. 90–96.Chen C.M. CiteSpace II: Detecting and Visualizing Emerging Trends and Transient Patterns in Scientific Literature // Journal of the American Society for Information Science and Technology. 2005. Vol. 57. Is. 3. P. 359–377. DOI: 10.1002/asi.20317Chen C.M. (2005) CiteSpace II: Detecting and Visualizing Emerging Trends and Transient Patterns in Scientific Literature. Journal of the American Society for Information Science and Technology. Vol. 57. Is. 3. P. 359–377. DOI: 10.1002/asi.20317Chen Y.H., Gao E.P. Suggestions on Improving Employment Security Review in Foreign Investment Law // Academic Journal of Zhongzhou. 2018. Vol. 4 P. 50–56.Chen Y.H., Gao E.P. (2018) Suggestions on Improving Employment Security Review in Foreign Investment Law. Academic Journal of Zhongzhou. Vol. 4 P. 50–56.Chen Z., Zhong Y.W. Evaluation of China’s Foreign Investment Security Review System under the New Development Pattern: Progress, Limitations and Improvement // International Business Research. 2021. Vol. 4. P. 87–97.Chen Z., Zhong Y.W. (2021) Evaluation of China’s Foreign Investment Security Review System under the New Development Pattern: Progress, Limitations and Improvement. International Business Research. Vol. 4. P. 87–97.Chen Y.D., Feng C.C. Analysis of the United States’ National Security Review System in Foreign Investment and China’s Countermeasures // Hunan University of Science & Technology (Social Science Edition). 2018. Vol. 3. P. 104–112.Chen Y.D., Feng C.C. (2018) Analysis of the United States’ National Security Review System in Foreign Investment and China’s Countermeasures. Hunan University of Science & Technology (Social Science Edition). Vol. 3. P. 104–112.Chin G.T. An Uncomfortable Truth: Canada’s Wary Ambivalence to Chinese Corporate Takeovers // International Journal. 2018. Vol. 73. Is. 3. P. 399–428. DOI: 10.1177/0020702018792917Chin G.T. (2018) An Uncomfortable Truth: Canada’s Wary Ambivalence to Chinese Corporate Takeovers. International Journal. Vol. 73. Is. 3. P. 399–428. DOI: 10.1177/0020702018792917Fang Y., Tian Z. Study on New Trends, Impacts and Response Strategies of U.S. Foreign Investment Security Review // Theoretical Investigation. 2020. Vol. 6. P. 14–19.Fang Y., Tian Z. (2020) Study on New Trends, Impacts and Response Strategies of U.S. Foreign Investment Security Review. Theoretical Investigation. Vol. 6. P. 14–19.Ge S.Q., Lin L., Chen J.Y. Chinese Enterprises’ Cross-border Mergers and Acquisitions and the New System of Host Country Security Review // Intertrade. 2019. Vol. 10. P. 49–57.Ge S.Q., Lin L., Chen J.Y. (2019) Chinese Enterprises’ Cross-border Mergers and Acquisitions and the New System of Host Country Security Review. Intertrade. Vol. 10. P. 49–57.Han B., Xu Q.Y. The Necessity of Financial Industry into Security Review // China Finance. 2021. Vol. 7. P. 74–75.Han B., Xu Q.Y. (2021) The Necessity of Financial Industry into Security Review. China Finance. Vol. 7. P. 74–75.Han C.L. International Cooperation on Antitrust Review of Cross-Border Mergers and Acquisitions: From the Case of NXP’s Acquisition of Freescale // Intertrade. 2017. Vol. 3. P. 58–62.Han C.L. (2017) International Cooperation on Antitrust Review of Cross-Border Mergers and Acquisitions: From the Case of NXP’s Acquisition of Freescale. Intertrade. Vol. 3. P. 58–62.Hu Z.N. Germany’s Enhanced Review of Foreign Direct Investment and its Impact on China — An Analysis Based on the Revision of the Foreign Economic Regulations // Contemporary International Relations. 2019a. Vol. 6. P. 10–18.Hu Z.N. (2019) Germany’s Enhanced Review of Foreign Direct Investment and its Impact on China — An Analysis Based on the Revision of the Foreign Economic Regulations. Contemporary International Relations. Vol. 6. P. 10–18.Hu Z.N. The Impact and Response of the EU’s First FDI Security Review Mechanism // Social Sciences. 2019b. Vol. 10. P. 42–51.Hu Z.N. (2019) The Impact and Response of the EU’s First FDI Security Review Mechanism. Social Sciences. Vol. 10. P. 42–51.Hu Z.H., Jia Y.Z., Yu X. Study on the US Foreign Investment Security Review Mechanism and its Impact on China // Public Finance Research. 2017. Vol. 5. P. 89–99.Hu Z.H., Jia Y.Z., Yu X. (2017) Study on the US Foreign Investment Security Review Mechanism and its Impact on China. Public Finance Research. Vol. 5. P. 89–99.Hu Z.N., Qin Y. The New Trend and Implication of U.S. Tightening the National Security Review of FDI and the Countermeasures // Intertrade. 2020. Vol. 4. P. 64–71.Hu Z.N., Qin Y. (2020) The New Trend and Implication of U. S. Tightening the National Security Review of FDI and the Countermeasures. Intertrade. Vol. 4. P. 64–71.Huang X. Reflections on the Improvement of China’s National Security Review System // Intertrade. 2016. Vol. 6. P. 59–62.Huang X. (2016) Reflections on the Improvement of China’s National Security Review System. Intertrade. Vol. 6. P. 59–62.Hundt D. The Changing Role of the FIRB and the Politics of Foreign Investment in Australia // Australian Journal of Political Science. 2020. Vol. 55. Is. 3. P. 328–343. DOI: 10.1080/10361146.2020.1766415Hundt D. (2020) The Changing Role of the FIRB and the Politics of Foreign Investment in Australia. Australian Journal of Political Science. Vol. 55. Is. 3. P. 328–343. DOI: 10.1080/10361146.2020.1766415Ji C., Guo J.X. The Historical Changes Institutional Design and China’s Response of U. S. National Security Review Institutional in Foreign Investment // Intertrade. 2019. Vol. 6. P. 69–78.Ji C., Guo J.X. (2019) The Historical Changes Institutional Design and China’s Response of U.S. National Security Review Institutional in Foreign Investment. Intertrade. Vol. 6. P. 69–78.Jiang X.F., Zhang Q.L. Study on the Legal Framework for Screening Foreign Direct Investment in the European Union — From the Prospective of Industrial Policy // Suibe. 2019. Vol. 26. P. 84–98.Jiang X.F., Zhang Q.L. (2019) Study on the Legal Framework for Screening Foreign Direct Investment in the European Union — From the Prospective of Industrial Policy. Suibe. Vol. 26. P. 84–98.Kong Q.J. The Convergence and Coordination of the Foreign Investment Law of the People’s Republic of China and Related Laws // Shanghai University of International Business and Economics. 2019. Vol. 3. P. 5–13.Kong Q.J. (2019) The Convergence and Coordination of the Foreign Investment Law of the People’s Republic of China and Related Laws. Shanghai University of International Business and Economics. Vol. 3. P. 5–13.Leng S. The Appraisal of European Union Framework for Screening Foreign Direct Investments and Countermeasures: Based on the Regulation Establishing a Framework for Screening Foreign Direct Investment in EU // Modern Law Science. 2019. Vol. 41. P. 194–209.Leng S. (2019) The Appraisal of European Union Framework for Screening Foreign Direct Investments and Countermeasures: Based on the Regulation Establishing a Framework for Screening Foreign Direct Investment in EU. Modern Law Science. Vol. 41. P. 194–209.Li F.N., Yue L. Routes and Choices of Dispute Settlement for US Investment under National Security Review // Wuhan University of Technology (Social Science Edition). 2016. Vol. 3. P. 485–490.Li F.N., Yue L. (2016) Routes and Choices of Dispute Settlement for US Investment under National Security Review. Wuhan University of Technology (Social Science Edition). Vol. 3. P. 485–490.Li J. National Security Review System in Cross-border Investment of China’s Enterprises // Proceedings of 2018 7th International Conference on Social Science, Education and Humanities Research (SSEHR 2018). Xi’an, 2018. P. 411–416. DOI: 10.25236/ssehr.2018.080Li J. (2018) National Security Review System in Cross-border Investment of China’s Enterprises. Proceedings of 2018 7th International Conference on Social Science, Education and Humanities Research (SSEHR 2018). Xi’an. P. 411–416. DOI: 10.25236/ssehr.2018.080Li W., Zhao L. Institutional Changes in U.S. National Security Review of Foreign Investment and Their Impacts on China // Global Review. 2019. Vol. 1. P. 44–71+159.Li W., Zhao L. (2019) Institutional Changes in U.S. National Security Review of Foreign Investment and Their Impacts on China. Global Review. Vol. 1. P. 44–71+159.Li Z.Q. Controversy and Solutions Concerning the US National Economic Security Review System // Frontiers. 2019. Vol. 19. P. 104–107.Li Z.Q. (2019) Controversy and Solutions Concerning the US National Economic Security Review System. Frontiers. Vol. 19. P. 104–107.Lin L., Hu T. New Trends in U.S. Foreign Investment Security Review from FIRRMA // International Economic Cooperation. 2018. Vol. 8. P. 12–15.Lin L., Hu T. (2018) New Trends in U.S. Foreign Investment Security Review from FIRRMA. International Economic Cooperation. Vol. 8. P. 12–15.Liu Y., Sun B. On Technology Export Control from the Perspective of Linkage Relationship with National Security Review of Foreign Investment and China’s Countermeasures // Intertrade. 2020. Vol. 6. P. 72–79.Liu Y., Sun B. (2020) On Technology Export Control from the Perspective of Linkage Relationship with National Security Review of Foreign Investment and China’s Countermeasures. Intertrade. Vol. 6. P. 72–79.Lian Z., Wang Y., Sun W.L. The National Security Review Regime on Investment Activities under the Trump Administration: New Features and Their Reasons // International Forum. 2019. Vol. 2. P. 112–124 +158–159.Lian Z., Wang Y., Sun W.L. (2019) The National Security Review Regime on Investment Activities under the Trump Administration: New Features and Their Reasons. International Forum. Vol. 2. P. 112–124+158–159.Liao F. Foreign Investment Law: Background, Innovation and Prospect // Xiamen University (Arts & Social Sciences). 2020. Vol. 3. P. 140–149.Liao F. (2020) Foreign Investment Law: Background, Innovation and Prospect. Xiamen University (Arts & Social Sciences). Vol. 3. P. 140–149.Ma N. The Guarantee Function and Realization Path of National Network Security Review System // Global Law Review. 2016. Vol. 5. P. 134–150.Ma N. (2016) The Guarantee Function and Realization Path of National Network Security Review System. Global Law Review. Vol. 5. P. 134–150.Pang M.C., Zhu H., Liu J. Reform of China’s Foreign Investment Access System Based on Pre-Entry National Treatment Plus Negative List Management // Macroeconomics. 2014. Vol. 12. P. 12–18+41.Pang M.C., Zhu H., Liu J. (2014) Reform of China’s Foreign Investment Access System Based on Pre-Entry National Treatment Plus Negative List Management. Macroeconomics. Vol. 12. P. 12–18+41.Qi T. On the Judicial Review of National Security Screening Decision of Foreign Investment // Wuhan University Journal (Philosophy & Social Science). 2020. Vol. 3 P. 142–150.Qi T. (2020) On the Judicial Review of National Security Screening Decision of Foreign Investment. Wuhan University Journal (Philosophy & Social Science). Vol. 3. P. 142–150.Ren C.Y. Reform of Foreign Investment System in China’s Pilot Free Trade Zone // Enterprise Economy. 2017. Vol. 10. P. 164–170.Ren C.Y. (2017) Reform of Foreign Investment System in China’s Pilot Free Trade Zone. Enterprise Economy. Vol. 10. P. 164–170.Sun J., Wang Y.R. Deficiencies of the EU’ s New FDI Review Mechanism and China’s Response // Practice in Foreign Economic Relations and Trade. 2020. Vol. 12. P. 8–11.Sun J., Wang Y.R. (2020) Deficiencies of the EU’ s New FDI Review Mechanism and China’s Response. Practice in Foreign Economic Relations and Trade. Vol. 12. P. 8–11.Sun N.S., Peng Y. Legislative Improvement and Perfection Measures of the National Security Review System for Foreign-Invested Mergers and Acquisitions // Academia Bimestris. 2014. Vol. 3. P. 145–151.Sun N.S., Peng Y. (2014) Legislative Improvement and Perfection Measures of the National Security Review System for Foreign-Invested Mergers and Acquisitions. Academia Bimestris. Vol. 3. P. 145–151.Sun Y.X. International Experiences of Negative List Management for Foreign Investment: The Case of China (Shanghai) Pilot Free Trade Zone // Reform. 2014. Vol. 10. P. 37–45.Sun Y.X. (2014) International Experiences of Negative List Management for Foreign Investment: The Case of China (Shanghai) Pilot Free Trade Zone. Reform. Vol. 10. P. 37–45.Tao L.F. Accountability Analysis of National Security Review of Foreign Investment // Law Science. 2016. Vol. 1. P. 67–75.Tao L.F. (2016) Tao L.F. (2016) Accountability Analysis of National Security Review of Foreign Investment. Law Science. Vol. 1. P. 67–75.Tu X.Q., Shi D.S. Research on the System of Foreign Participation in PPP Projects in China // Study & Exploration. 2016. Vol. 1. P. 111–116.Tu X.Q., Shi D.S. (2016) Research on the System of Foreign Participation in PPP Projects in China. Study & Exploration. Vol. 1. P. 111–116.Tu X.Q., Zhou J.K. The Influence of the U.S.A. National Security Review of Foreign Merger and Acquisition Towards State-owned Enterprises of China and the Related Suggestions // Tsinghua University (Philosophy and Social Sciences). 2016. Vol. 5. P. 74–83+194.Tu X.Q., Zhou J.K. (2016) The Influence of the U.S.A. National Security Review of Foreign Merger and Acquisition Towards State-owned Enterprises of China and the Related Suggestions. Tsinghua University (Philosophy and Social Sciences). Vol. 5. P. 74–83+194.Wang D.G. National Security Review: Legalization of Politics and Politicization of Law // Peking University Law Journal. 2016. Vol. 5. P. 1289–1313.Wang D.G. (2016) National Security Review: Legalization of Politics and Politicization of Law. Peking University Law Journal. Vol. 5. P. 1289–1313.Wu C.H. On the Review Organization and Scope of China’s National Financial Security // Law Science Magazine. 2020. Vol. 3. P. 18–29+2.Wu C.H. (2020) On the Review Organization and Scope of China’s National Financial Security. Law Science Magazine. Vol. 3. P. 18–29+2.Ying H.H. Analysis of the Impact of Economic and Political Changes in Europe on Chinese Enterprises’ Trade and Investment in Europe // Practice in Foreign Economic Relations and Trade. 2019. Vol. 11. P. 16–19.Ying H.H. (2019) Analysis of the Impact of Economic and Political Changes in Europe on Chinese Enterprises’ Trade and Investment in Europe. Practice in Foreign Economic Relations and Trade. Vol. 11. P. 16–19.Zhang G.P. A Legal Interpretation of Pre-Establishment National Treatment Plus Negative List // Jiangsu Social Sciences. 2015. Vol. 3. P. 140–146.Zhang G.P. (2015) A Legal Interpretation of Pre-Establishment National Treatment Plus Negative List. Jiangsu Social Sciences. Vol. 3. P. 140–146.Zhang J.P., Liu H. 40 Years of Reform and Opening Up: ‘Bringing in’ and ‘Going Out’ // Pioneers. 2019. Vol. 2. P. 37–40.Zhang J.P., Liu H. (2019) 40 Years of Reform and Opening Up: ‘Bringing in’ and ‘Going Out’. Pioneers. Vol. 2. P. 37–40.Zhang H.L. Enhanced Foreign Investment Security Review in the U.S. and Europe and Its Impact // International Studies. 2019. Vol. 5. P. 65–85.Zhang H.L. (2019) Enhanced Foreign Investment Security Review in the U.S. and Europe and Its Impact. International Studies. Vol. 5. P. 65–85.Zhang H.L. Path and Influence of British Foreign Investment Review Reform under the Background of Openness and Security Balance // Intertrade. 2020. Vol. 9. P. 68–75.Zhang H.L. (2020) Path and Influence of British Foreign Investment Review Reform under the Background of Openness and Security Balance. Intertrade. Vol. 9. P. 68–75.Zhang G. On Relief Approaches of National Security Review under International Investment Arbitration // International Business Research. 2019. Vol. 5. P. 55–62.Zhang G. (2019) On Relief Approaches of National Security Review under International Investment Arbitration. International Business Research. Vol. 5. P. 55–62.Zhang Y.Y. Tightening Global Investment Security Review and Reconstruction of International Investment Pattern // Studies of International Finance. 2019. Vol. 1. P. 8.Zhang Y.Y. (2019) Tightening Global Investment Security Review and Reconstruction of International Investment Pattern. Studies of International Finance. Vol. 1. P. 8.Zhang X.T. Current Trends in International Investment Agreements and China’s Response // Frontiers. 2017. Vol. 5. P. 69–75.Zhang X.T. (2017) Current Trends in International Investment Agreements and China’s Response. Frontiers. Vol. 5. P. 69–75.Zhao B.W. New Trends in Global Foreign Investment Security Reviews and Their Impact on China // World Economy Studies. 2020. Vol. 6. P. 3–10+135.Zhao B.W. (2020) New Trends in Global Foreign Investment Security Reviews and Their Impact on China. World Economy Studies. Vol. 6. P. 3–10+135.Zhao J.J. A Comparative Study on the “Pre-Establishment National Treatment” of Banking Foreign Investment: From the Perspective of Practice in China(Shanghai) Pilot Free Trade Zone // International Economics and Trade Research. 2018. Vol. 2. P. 69–82.Zhao J.J. (2018) A Comparative Study on the “Pre-Establishment National Treatment” of Banking Foreign Investment: From the Perspective of Practice in China(Shanghai) Pilot Free Trade Zone. International Economics and Trade Research. Vol. 2. P. 69–82.Zhao J.Z., Ding G.N. The Security Review of the United States on the Investment and Merger of Chinese HighTech Enterprises and China’s Countermeasures // Asia-pacific Economic Review. 2020. Vol. 1. P. 71–79+151.Zhao J.Z., Ding G.N. (2020) The Security Review of the United States on the Investment and Merger of Chinese High-Tech Enterprises and China’s Countermeasures. Asia-pacific Economic Review. Vol. 1. P. 71–79+151.Zheng Z.Y., Chen D.M. Knowledge Map of Environmental Law Research CSSCI (2009–2019), Literature Metering Analysis Based on Citespace // Arid Land Resources and Environment. 2020. Vol. 6. P. 62–72.Zheng Z.Y., Chen D.M. (2020) Knowledge Map of Environmental Law Research CSSCI (2009–2019), Literature Metering Analysis Based on CiteSpace. Arid Land Resources and Environment. Vol. 6. P. 62–72.

The authors declare that there are no conflicts of interest present.